2nd Guesser

DEMOCRACY AT IT FINEST

What is second guesser

Second Guesser is a company that helps individuals make informed decisions by providing insights and guidance through the collective input of others. By leveraging voting and feedback from a community, Second Guesser allows people to gain diverse perspectives and make more confident, well-rounded choices. The platform fosters collaboration and offers a unique way to gather opinions, ensuring users can consider multiple viewpoints before making important decisions.

Should I break up with my boyfriend?

I (26F) have been in a relationship with my boyfriend “Jake ” (28M) for almost 2 years. We get along really well most of the time, but there have been a few recurring issues that have been weighing on me lately.

About six months ago, Jake asked if he could move in with me, and I agreed. At first, everything seemed fine, but over time, I’ve started noticing some things that have been bothering me. He’s incredibly messy—he leaves his clothes all over the apartment, doesn’t clean up after himself, and expects me to do it all. I’ve tried talking to him about it multiple times, and he just brushes it off or says that he’ll “try harder,” but nothing ever changes.

Another issue is that jake is often very dismissive when it comes to my career and ambitions. I work long hours, and I’m very passionate about my job, but whenever I talk about something I’m excited about, he either changes the subject or makes jokes about me being “too busy.” It’s started to feel like he doesn’t take me seriously, and it’s really starting to affect my confidence.

What really got to me recently, though, was when I had a big presentation at work, and I asked him if he could help me prep a little. I was feeling nervous, and I thought it would be nice if he showed some support. Instead, he barely acknowledged it and spent the evening playing video games, saying that I should “just handle it.” I ended up doing everything alone, and it felt so isolating.

I’ve talked to him about how I feel a few times, but it’s always the same story. He says he’ll change, but the behavior never really improves. I love him, but I’m starting to wonder if I’m settling for someone who isn’t giving me the emotional support I need.

So, should I break up with my boyfriend?

Loading poll …
Loading poll …
Should I Smash My Wife’s Annoying Alarm Clock?

Should I Smash My Wife’s Annoying Alarm Clock?

Hey everyone, I need some advice—and maybe a little moral support.

My wife has this alarm clock that’s unreasonably loud and seems to have no concept of mercy. It goes off at the crack of dawn, blaring like it’s trying to wake the entire neighborhood. To make matters worse, she has this habit of hitting snooze multiple times, so I’m subjected to the same auditory assault over and over again.

I’ve tried talking to her about it, suggesting maybe she use her phone instead, or at least tone down the volume. But she swears by this alarm clock and insists it’s the only thing that gets her up in the morning. Meanwhile, I’m lying there, plotting its demise.

So here’s the question: Should I smash the alarm clock and plead insanity later? Or is there a more peaceful (and marriage-preserving) solution I haven’t thought of?

I’m open to ideas, stories, or just solidarity if anyone’s been in the same boat. Help me save my mornings—and my sanity!

Loading poll …

Is It Really Profitable to Make Money on Social Media?

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about whether making money on social media is actually worth it. You always hear about influencers and content creators pulling in six or even seven figures, but is that realistic for the average person?

From what I’ve seen, there are definitely ways to make money—brand deals, affiliate marketing, ad revenue, selling your own products—but it takes time, consistency, and a real strategy. It’s not just about posting random content and hoping it goes viral. The algorithms are tricky, competition is crazy, and unless you already have a big audience, it’s an uphill battle.

That being said, I know people who’ve built side hustles into full-time incomes. So maybe it’s not impossible, but I’m wondering—how profitable is it really? Have any of you made real money from social media? What’s your experience been like? Let me know!

Loading poll …
Is Remodeling My House Really Worth It?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if remodeling my house is actually worth it. I love the idea of updating things and making it feel more like my dream home, but the cost, the time, and the stress of it all are making me hesitate.

I’ve seen people start small projects that turn into never-ending nightmares, and I don’t want to get stuck in that. At the same time, I know a remodel could add value and make the space way more enjoyable.

For those who’ve done it—was it worth the hassle? Or do you wish you had just left things the way they were? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

Should I Just Move Instead of Remodeling?

I saw a post the other day about someone wondering if remodeling their house was worth it, and it got me thinking—should I even bother remodeling, or would it be easier to just move?

There are a lot of things I’d love to change about my place, but between the cost, the time, and the stress of renovations, I’m starting to wonder if it would be smarter to find a home that already has what I want. At the same time, moving is a huge hassle too, and I do have a lot of memories here.

For those who’ve been in this situation—did you choose to remodel, or did you end up moving? Looking back, was it the right choice? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Is Putting My Mom in a Care Home the Right Choice?

Lately, I’ve been struggling with the idea of moving my mom into a care home. She’s always been independent, but as she gets older, it’s becoming harder for her to manage on her own. I want to be there for her, but between work, family, and life in general, I’m starting to wonder if she’d be better off somewhere with full-time care.

The guilt is the hardest part. I don’t want her to feel like I’m abandoning her, but I also don’t want to wait until something bad happens before making a decision. I know people say it can be the best thing for their health and safety, but it still feels like such a heavy choice.

For those who’ve been through this—how did you know when it was the right time? And how did you deal with the guilt? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Is It Time to Move?

Lately, I’ve been thinking about whether it’s time to move. As I get older, keeping up with the yard work has become more of a hassle than I’d like to admit. Mowing, weeding, trimming—it’s just not as easy as it used to be. I’d hire someone, but finding reliable yard care around here is tougher than you’d think.

I never thought I’d consider moving just because of something like this, but the idea of a low-maintenance home—maybe a condo or a place with a smaller yard—is starting to sound pretty appealing. Still, leaving a home I’ve been in for years isn’t an easy decision.

Has anyone else made a move for reasons like this? Was it worth it in the long run? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Should I Take a High-Paying Job Even Though It’s for Scumbags?
Full audio can be found on post:https://2ndguesser.com/should-i-take-a-high-paying-job-even-though-its-for-scumbags/

I stared at my laptop screen, the email glowing like a taunt.

“We’re impressed with your experience in community outreach and believe you’d be an asset to our team. The offer includes a salary of $180,000, plus benefits.”

$180,000. Nearly three times what I was making now. My rent would be an afterthought. My student loans? Gone. I could finally get my car fixed instead of praying it didn’t break down every morning. Hell, I could even help my mom out with her medical bills.

It all sounded great, except for one thing: the job was at a real estate firm. (I’ll just call them “the real estate firm” for legal reasons.)

I knew what they did. I had seen their work up close. They bought up properties in struggling neighborhoods, kicked out the families living there, and turned those places into overpriced condos. I had spent the last five years working for a nonprofit trying to help those same families stay in their homes.

And now this company wanted to pay me a small fortune to join them.

I texted my best friend Aaron: Can I call you? Need to talk.

A few minutes later, he picked up. “Dude, what’s up?”

“I got a job offer,” I said. “$180K.”

Aaron whistled. “Damn. Where?”

I hesitated. “A real estate firm.”

“…The real estate firm?”

“Yeah.”

Silence. Then a laugh. “And what’s the problem?”

I sighed. “You know exactly what the problem is.”

Aaron made a dismissive noise. “Dude, come on. You wouldn’t be the one kicking people out. You’d just be working there. Do you want to be broke forever?”

“It’s not just about money. How do I sleep at night knowing I’m part of the problem?”

“Okay, so go in and change things from the inside,” he said. “They’re offering you serious money. You think they’ll stop if you say no? Someone else will take that job in a second.”

I had no response to that. He wasn’t wrong, but it didn’t sit right with me either.

That night, lying in bed, I scrolled through a career advice forum. I typed out my dilemma:

Offered a high-paying job, but the company’s ethics don’t align with mine. Do I take it for financial security or stick with my passion?

The replies were all over the place.

One person wrote: “Money is freedom. Take it.”

Another countered: “You already know the answer. If you take the job, you’ll hate yourself every day.”

Then this: “Try negotiating. Make it clear that you won’t support unethical practices. See what they say.”

That last one stuck with me.

The next morning, I called the hiring manager. After a few pleasantries, I said, “I appreciate the offer, but I have concerns. I’ve spent years advocating for affordable housing. If I were to come on board, I’d want to be involved in projects that ensure residents aren’t displaced unfairly.”

There was a pause. Then a short laugh. “I admire your passion, Jordan, but that’s not really what we’re looking for. We need someone to help us improve our public image, not fight our policies.”

And that was all I needed to hear.

“Then I’m going to have to decline,” I said, feeling lighter than I had in days.

A week later, my boss at the nonprofit called me into her office. “We heard about the job offer you turned down,” she said.

I braced myself for her to tell me I’d made a mistake.

Instead, she smiled. “That kind of integrity is rare. We can’t match their offer, but we can give you a raise. And we want you to lead a new initiative—one that will directly help families find stable housing.”

I walked out of her office knowing I’d made the right call.

Money’s important. But being able to look at yourself in the mirror every morning? That’s priceless.

Loading poll …
Do My Pets Feel Lonely When I’m Gone?

Lately, I’ve been feeling guilty about leaving my pets home alone all day. Between work, errands, and just life in general, I’m out of the house more than I’d like to be, and I can’t help but wonder—do they feel lonely?

I make sure they have food, water, and toys, but it’s not the same as actual company. I see people installing pet cameras, hiring dog walkers, or even getting a second pet to keep theirs company, and I’m starting to wonder if I should be doing more.

For other pet owners—how do you handle being away for long hours? Do your pets seem fine, or have you noticed changes in their behavior? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

Am I Making the Most of University?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if I’m really making the most of my time at university. Everyone says these are supposed to be the best years of your life, but between classes, assignments, and trying to figure out what I actually want to do after graduation, it feels more stressful than exciting.

I see people joining clubs, going to parties, networking, traveling—and sometimes I feel like I’m just stuck in a cycle of studying and barely keeping up. Am I supposed to have it all figured out by now? Or is it normal to feel like you’re just going through the motions?

For those who’ve been through this—how did you make the most of your time at university? Any advice on balancing work, social life, and actually enjoying the experience? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Was I Too Harsh?

I (29F) work as a marketing manager at a mid-sized company. My coworker, Jessica (31F), and I are on the same team, and we’ve always had a friendly rivalry when it comes to landing new clients. However, recently I discovered that Jessica has been directly contacting my clients behind my back and offering them better deals with the promise of working on their future projects.

I confronted her, and she admitted to it, saying she felt my pitches were “outdated” and that she could do a better job with the clients. I felt betrayed, especially because these clients were my responsibility, and I had built a solid relationship with them.

I went to my boss and reported her actions. Jessica was fired for breach of company protocol. Now, she’s blaming me, saying I should’ve handled it more professionally and that I ruined her career over “a little competition.”

My coworkers are split, with some saying I did the right thing and others saying I was too harsh.

Was I too harsh by reporting her and getting her fired?

Loading poll …
Should I Buy a House in This Economy?

Should I Buy a House in This Economy?

Hey everyone, I’m looking for some advice.

I’ve been considering buying a house, but with the current state of the economy, I’m honestly not sure if it’s the right time. Interest rates are higher than they’ve been in years, and home prices in my area still feel inflated. On the other hand, renting doesn’t seem like the best option long-term, especially with rents rising year after year.

I’m worried about overextending myself financially if prices drop or if the market slows down further. But at the same time, I don’t want to miss out if prices or rates go even higher.

For context:

  • I have a stable job and decent savings for a down payment.
  • I’d be buying primarily to live in, not as an investment.
  • I’m not in a rush but would like to make a move in the next year or so.

What do you all think? Is it better to wait and see how things play out, or should I take the plunge and buy now? I’d love to hear from anyone who’s bought recently or decided to hold off.

Thanks in advance for your insights!

Loading poll …

“Should I Start My Own Electrician Business?”

“Should I Start My Own Electrician Business?”

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about taking the leap and starting my own electrician business. I’ve got years of experience in the field, but there’s something about the idea of running my own company that feels both exciting and nerve-wracking at the same time. On one hand, I know I can offer quality work, and I’d love the freedom of being my own boss. On the other, I’m worried about the financial risks, finding clients, and all the logistics that come with starting a business.

Has anyone here made the jump to starting their own trade business, specifically in the electrical field? How did you know it was the right time? What challenges should I be prepared for? I’d love to hear your stories, tips, or any advice on getting started and navigating the journey!

Loading poll …

Am I Wrong for Calling Out My Manager for Taking Credit for My Work in a Meeting?

I (25F) work at a large company where I’m part of a small team, and we’re currently handling a major project. I’ve been working tirelessly on it for the last two months, and my manager (40M) is aware of the effort I’ve been putting in.

However, during a big presentation, he took full credit for my work in front of our senior management team and claimed he had been behind all the ideas that led to our project’s success.

I couldn’t stay silent, so I corrected him in front of everyone, saying that while I appreciated his leadership, the ideas and implementation were my work. There was an awkward silence, and the meeting ended soon after.

Now, he’s mad at me, and some coworkers think I should’ve handled it more privately. Others say I had every right to stand up for myself.

AITA for calling out my boss in front of the team?

Loading poll …
 AITA for not letting my roommate borrow my clothes?

 AITA for not letting my roommate borrow my clothes?

I (25F) have a roommate, Lisa (24F), who’s always borrowing my clothes without asking. At first, I didn’t mind it too much, but it’s been getting out of hand. She’ll take things like my expensive jackets or my favorite shoes, and when I ask for them back, she takes forever or forgets to return them altogether.

I’ve confronted her about this multiple times, but she brushes it off or says I’m overreacting. Last week, I bought a new dress for a special occasion, and she took it without even asking. I told her if she wanted to borrow it, she needed to ask first, and she got offended, saying I was being too controlling.

Now she’s giving me the silent treatment, and I feel like I’m being unreasonable. AITA for setting boundaries about my clothes?

Loading poll …

Is It Too Late to Start Over?

Lately, I’ve been wondering— is it ever too late to start over? Whether it’s changing careers, moving to a new place, or even just picking up a new hobby, there’s always that little voice in my head saying, “You should have done this sooner.”

I see people reinventing themselves at all ages, but I also know how hard it can be to walk away from what’s comfortable. Is it worth the risk, or is there a point where you just have to accept where you are?

What do you think—is it ever truly too late to start over? Yes or no?

Loading poll …
Is Having Kids Really Worth It?

Lately, I’ve been thinking a lot about whether having kids is really worth it. I see people talk about how fulfilling and life-changing it is, but I also see how exhausted, stressed, and financially drained parents can be.

Raising a child is a huge commitment—time, money, energy— and once you do it, there’s no going back. I know everyone says “it’s different when they’re your own,” but what if it’s not? What if I make the wrong choice, one way or the other?

For those who have kids—was it truly worth it? And for those who decided not to—do you ever regret it? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

AITA for refusing to babysit my niece because I was busy?

 AITA for refusing to babysit my niece because I was busy?

I (30M) was asked by my sister (32F) to babysit my 5-year-old niece this weekend while she and her husband go on a quick trip. I’ve helped out in the past, but this time, I already had plans with friends that I had been looking forward to for weeks.

I told her I couldn’t babysit because I didn’t want to cancel my plans, and she got upset. She said I should’ve planned ahead since she’d already booked the trip, and that as family, I should always prioritize helping out.

I understand where she’s coming from, but I don’t feel like I should have to give up my personal time every time she asks. She’s now angry with me, and I’m wondering if I’m being selfish. AITA for not babysitting?

Loading poll …

Should I Move Out?

Lately, I’ve been thinking about whether it’s time to move out. Living at home has its perks—saving money, home-cooked meals, not having to worry about rent—but at the same time, I feel like I’m missing out on independence.

A lot of my friends have already moved into their own places, and I can’t help but wonder if I’m falling behind. But with rent prices so high and the cost of living getting worse, is it even worth it right now?

For those who’ve moved out, was it the right decision? Do you wish you waited longer, or was it the best thing you ever did? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Should I Let My Roommate Off the Hook?

I (27F) live with my roommate (26F), who recently lost her job. I understand that things are tough for her, and I’ve been really supportive, even letting her stay at my place rent-free for the past month.

However, she hasn’t been actively looking for a new job and continues to use all the utilities without contributing to anything. She eats my food without offering to replace it, uses the heating and electricity all day, and hasn’t even helped with cleaning or other shared responsibilities.

Last night, I asked her if she would be willing to pay for utilities and contribute something toward rent until she gets back on her feet. She got angry and said I’m being “too harsh” and “unsupportive.”

I told her that I can’t continue to support her indefinitely and need some help with the expenses. Now, she’s threatening to move out, and our mutual friends say I’m being too demanding.

Should I let my roommate off the hook or stand firm?

Loading poll …
Am I Doing Enough as a School Mom?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if I’m doing enough as a school mom. Between homework, after-school activities, and just keeping up with everything, it sometimes feels like I’m barely holding it together. I see other moms volunteering for every event, packing Pinterest-worthy lunches, and always seeming so on top of things, and I can’t help but feel like I’m falling short.

I want to be involved, but between work, house chores, and just trying to find a little time for myself, it’s hard to do it all. I know every mom has their own struggles, but does the guilt ever go away?

For the moms out there—how do you balance it all? Do you ever feel like you’re doing enough, or is this just part of the parenting journey? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Is It Time to Stop Driving?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if it’s time to hang up the keys. I’ve been driving for decades, but lately, it feels more stressful than it used to. Traffic is worse, reaction times aren’t what they once were, and honestly, night driving is starting to feel like a gamble.

Public transportation isn’t great where I live, and relying on others isn’t something I’m used to. But at the same time, I don’t want to wait until something bad happens to make the decision.

Has anyone else gone through this? How did you know it was the right time to stop driving? And if you did, how did you adjust? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Is it fair to ask My Partner to Help Pay for the Bills After I Got Laid Off?


I (33M) have been with my partner (32F) for five years. We share a joint account for bills and living expenses. A few weeks ago, I was laid off and have been actively job hunting, but I haven’t secured anything yet.

In the meantime, I’ve been struggling to cover my share of the rent and utilities. I asked my partner if she could temporarily help until I find a new job. She got upset, saying I should have saved for situations like this and that it’s not her responsibility to pay for both of us—despite the fact that we’ve always shared expenses.

Now, there’s tension between us. I feel bad for putting her in this position, but I’m also hurt that she isn’t more understanding of my situation. Some friends say I shouldn’t have even asked and should have just figured it out on my own.

Is it fair to ask my partner for financial help while I’m unemployed?

Loading poll …
Am I Spending Too Much Time on Video Games?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if I’m spending too much time playing video games. It’s my go-to way to relax after a long day, and honestly, I enjoy it—but sometimes I catch myself thinking, “Could I be using this time for something more productive?”

I see people grinding at the gym, learning new skills, or working on side hustles, and meanwhile, I’m grinding for in-game rewards. Don’t get me wrong, gaming is fun, and I’ve made great friends through it, but I don’t want to look back and regret not doing more with my time.

For other gamers—how do you balance gaming with everything else? Have you ever cut back, or do you think it’s fine as long as you enjoy it? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

Should I Quit My Job to Become a Pokémon Trainer?

So, I had a realization at work today—why am I sitting here answering emails when I could be out there catching ‘em all? My boss says I need to “get my priorities straight,” but honestly, isn’t becoming a Pokémon Master the ultimate priority?

Picture it: I walk into the office, dramatically toss my resignation letter like it’s a Pokéball, and declare, “I choose ME!” Then I step outside, ready to embark on my journey… only to realize I don’t actually have a Pikachu, a Pokédex, or even decent walking shoes.

Would I miss my steady paycheck? Probably. Would I regret my decision when I’m camping in the middle of nowhere with nothing but a bag of stale chips and a dream? Maybe. But imagine the thrill of throwing a Pokéball at a wild encounter (even if, legally speaking, that “wild encounter” is just a confused squirrel in the park).

So, what do you think? Should I take the leap and pursue my destiny, or should I stay in my cubicle and continue battling spreadsheets instead of Gym Leaders?

Loading poll …
Are Used Cars Even Worth It Anymore?

Lately, I’ve been dealing with car problems, and it’s got me looking at used cars—but honestly, the prices are insane. I always thought buying second-hand was the cheaper option, but with how expensive they are now, I’m starting to wonder if it’s even worth it compared to just getting a new one.

Sure, new cars cost more upfront, but with warranties, better reliability, and sometimes even better financing options, it almost seems like the smarter choice. But at the same time, I don’t want to be stuck with a huge car payment.

For those who’ve bought a car recently—did you go used or new? Was it worth the price, or do you regret your choice? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

AITA for not letting my friend bring her kids to my wedding?

AITA for not letting my friend bring her kids to my wedding?

I (28F) am getting married in a few months, and I’ve been friends with jane (30F) for years. jane has two kids, ages 4 and 7, and I love them dearly. However, I have always envisioned my wedding as an adult-only event. I politely told Sarah this and explained that there would be no children invited to the wedding, except for a few close family members’ children.

She got upset, claiming I was being unfair and that she should be allowed to bring her kids because they’re her responsibility and she wants to be there. I tried to compromise and suggested that she could bring them to the ceremony but leave before the reception. She was still not happy and now says she may not attend at all because of this.

Now, I’m starting to feel guilty. She’s one of my best friends, and I don’t want to upset her. But this is my big day, and I’ve already set the guest list. AITA for sticking to my no-kids rule for my wedding?

Loading poll …

Preview

Should I Join the Army?

Should I Join the Army?

Hey everyone, I’m at a crossroads and could really use some insight. Lately, I’ve been seriously considering joining the Army, but I want to make the most informed decision possible.

For those of you with experience, either in the military or as someone close to someone who’s served, I have a few questions:

  • What were your biggest reasons for joining, and do you feel it was worth it?
  • What are some unexpected challenges or rewards I should prepare for?
  • How has it shaped your life—personally, professionally, or both?

I’m looking for honest thoughts, whether good or bad. I understand this is a deeply personal choice, but hearing about real experiences could really help me find clarity.

Thanks in advance for your time and advice!

Feel free to share your story or drop some general advice in the comments. 🙏

Loading poll …

Do High School Grades Really Matter This Much?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if my high school grades are as important as everyone makes them out to be. Teachers, parents, and everyone else keep saying they’ll determine my future, but honestly? I hate school. No matter how hard I try, some subjects just don’t click, and it’s frustrating to feel like my entire future depends on a bunch of numbers on a report card.

I get that grades matter for college and jobs, but do they really define everything? Are they worth all the stress, or is there more to success than just doing well in school?

For those who’ve been through it—do high school grades actually matter in the long run? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …

Am I Too Old to Be Collecting Plushies?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if I’m too old to be collecting plushies. I love them—they make me happy, they’re comforting, and honestly, hunting for rare ones is kind of exciting. But sometimes, I feel like people judge me for it, like I should have “grown out of it” by now.

I know everyone has their own hobbies, but I can’t help but wonder—should I feel weird about still loving plushies as an adult? Or does it really not matter as long as it makes me happy?

For those who collect—do you ever feel judged for it? Do you just ignore what people think? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
Is Investing in Stocks Really Worth It?

Lately, I’ve been wondering if investing in stocks is actually worth it or if it’s just overhyped. I see people talking about building wealth, passive income, and long-term gains, but at the same time, I hear horror stories about people losing everything.

I get that investing is a long game, but with the market going up and down constantly, it feels risky—especially when I don’t have a ton of money to throw in. Is it really something the average person should be doing, or is it just for people who already have money to spare?

For those who invest—has it actually paid off for you? Or is it more stressful than it’s worth? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Loading poll …
“Should I Quit My Job?

“Should I Quit My Job?

Lately, I’ve been feeling stuck, like I’m caught in an endless loop of the daily grind. My energy feels drained, and I’m beginning to wonder if I’m truly aligned with my passions or if I’m just going through the motions.

But here’s the thing—I’m scared. Scared of the uncertainty that comes with making a big change. What if I regret it? What if I fail? What if the grass isn’t greener on the other side?

I keep asking myself: Am I staying because it’s the right choice, or because it’s the safe choice? And if I leave, what’s the cost of that freedom?

To those who’ve stood in this space before me, I ask: What was your turning point? How did you find the courage to leap—or the wisdom to stay? I’m searching for clarity and would truly appreciate any advice or perspectives you can offer.”

Loading poll …

Title: AITA for not wanting to celebrate Christmas with my family after a disagreement about religion?

Title: AITA for not wanting to celebrate Christmas with my family after a disagreement about religion?

I (28M) come from a family that celebrates Christmas every year. It’s always a big, festive occasion with lots of gifts, food, and togetherness. However, this year, things have gotten complicated because my family has always been quite religious, and recently, they’ve been increasingly pushing their faith on me.

I am not very religious, and I’ve been more vocal about it over the past few years. I don’t mind people practicing their religion, but it’s gotten to the point where my family seems to expect me to join them in prayer and church services, and they even tried to convince me to become more devout.

The breaking point came when my mom said, “Christmas isn’t really about gifts, it’s about honoring the birth of Jesus Christ, and if you’re not willing to do that, maybe you shouldn’t be at the table this year.” I’ve always appreciated the spirit of Christmas—spending time with loved ones—but I feel like it’s no longer about that with my family.

I told her I wouldn’t attend the family gathering if I was being pressured to take part in religious rituals I’m not comfortable with. This has caused a huge rift. My parents are upset, my siblings are torn, and I’m feeling like the black sheep.

I feel like I’m being asked to compromise my values just to fit in with the family tradition, and I don’t think that’s fair. But my family thinks I’m being unreasonable and selfish for not being willing to “celebrate Christmas properly.”

So, AITA for refusing to go to Christmas if I’m pressured into religious activities?

Loading poll …

2nd Thoughts